10 Best Restaurants in St Augustine, FL
As a foodie and a resident of St Augustine, FL, I have scoured the city and compiled a list of the top 10 restaurants that you must try. From seafood to Italian to American cuisine, this city has it all. So, whether you are a local or a tourist, get ready to indulge in some of the best food that St Augustine has to offer.
Top 10 Restaurants in St Augustine, FL
- The Floridian
- Collage Restaurant
- The Columbia Restaurant
- The Blue Hen Cafe
- Gypsy Cab Company
- Ice Plant Bar
- Preserved Restaurant
- Catch 27
- Cap’s On The Water
- The Conch House Restaurant
Why These Restaurants Made the Cut
After conducting a survey of St Augustine locals and tourists, I analyzed the data and visited each of these restaurants to ensure that they meet the following criteria:
- Exceptional quality of food
- Ambiance and atmosphere
- Service and hospitality
- Value for money
Based on these factors, I have compiled a list of the top 10 restaurants in St Augustine, FL that are sure to satisfy your taste buds and leave you wanting more.
The Floridian
Located in the heart of St Augustine’s historic district, The Floridian offers a unique blend of Southern and Caribbean cuisine. From the shrimp and grits to the fried chicken, everything on the menu is made from scratch using locally sourced ingredients. I personally recommend trying their famous Datil Pepper Sauce.
The Floridian has a cozy atmosphere with indoor and outdoor seating options, making it the perfect spot for a romantic dinner or a casual lunch with friends.
Price Range: $$
Collage Restaurant
Collage Restaurant is a fine dining establishment that offers a fusion of French and Mediterranean cuisine. Their menu changes seasonally to ensure that they are using the freshest ingredients possible. I recommend trying the lamb chops or the lobster bisque.
The ambiance at Collage is elegant and sophisticated, making it the perfect spot for a special occasion or a date night. The service is impeccable, and the staff is knowledgeable about the menu and wine list.
Price Range: $$$
The Columbia Restaurant
The Columbia Restaurant is a St Augustine institution that has been serving up traditional Spanish cuisine since 1905. Their famous 1905 Salad is a must-try, and the paella is a crowd favorite.
The Columbia has a vibrant atmosphere with indoor and outdoor seating options. They also have a flamenco dance show on select nights, which adds to the overall experience.
Price Range: $$
The Blue Hen Cafe
The Blue Hen Cafe is a cozy breakfast and lunch spot that offers a variety of options for vegetarians and meat-eaters alike. Their avocado toast and breakfast burrito are my personal favorites.
The Blue Hen has a rustic and charming atmosphere with indoor and outdoor seating options. They also have a small market where you can purchase local goods and souvenirs.
Price Range: $
Gypsy Cab Company
Gypsy Cab Company is a funky and eclectic restaurant that offers a variety of cuisine options, including seafood, pasta, and burgers. Their shrimp and grits and fish tacos are must-tries.
Gypsy Cab Company has a lively atmosphere with indoor and outdoor seating options. They also have a full bar and live music on select nights.
Price Range: $$
Ice Plant Bar
Ice Plant Bar is a trendy spot that serves up craft cocktails and small plates. Their charcuterie board and Old Fashioned cocktail are my personal favorites.
The atmosphere at Ice Plant Bar is industrial-chic with exposed brick and vintage decor. They also have a distillery on-site where they produce their own gin and vodka.
Price Range: $$
Preserved Restaurant
Preserved Restaurant offers Southern cuisine with a twist. Their menu changes seasonally to ensure that they are using the freshest ingredients possible. I recommend trying the deviled eggs and the pork chop.
Preserved has a cozy and intimate atmosphere with indoor and outdoor seating options. They also have a full bar and an extensive wine list.
Price Range: $$$
Catch 27
Catch 27 is a seafood restaurant that prides itself on using sustainable and locally sourced ingredients. Their fish tacos and shrimp and grits are must-tries.
Catch 27 has a modern and inviting atmosphere with indoor and outdoor seating options. They also have a full bar and an extensive wine list.
Price Range: $$
Cap’s On The Water
Cap’s On The Water is a waterfront restaurant that offers a variety of seafood and steak options. Their lobster tail and filet mignon are my personal favorites.
Cap’s has a relaxed and casual atmosphere with indoor and outdoor seating options. They also have a full bar and live music on select nights.
Price Range: $$$
The Conch House Restaurant
The Conch House Restaurant is a Caribbean-inspired restaurant that offers a variety of seafood and island-inspired dishes. Their conch fritters and jerk chicken are must-tries.
The Conch House has a laid-back and tropical atmosphere with indoor and outdoor seating options. They also have a full bar and live music on select nights.
Price Range: $$
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the best time to visit these restaurants?
I recommend making reservations in advance, especially during peak tourist season (March-August). Lunchtime is generally less crowded than dinner time.
Do these restaurants offer vegetarian and gluten-free options?
Yes, all of these restaurants offer vegetarian and gluten-free options. Some restaurants may require advance notice for special dietary needs.
What is the dress code at these restaurants?
The dress code varies depending on the restaurant. Collage Restaurant and Cap’s On The Water have a smart-casual dress code, while The Floridian and The Blue Hen Cafe have a more casual dress code. It is best to check with the restaurant beforehand.